Main Site | About BHS | Visitor Information | Exhibitions | Education | Library | Publications| Support BHS Press | Contact us | Online Store | Site Map
 

McCarthy

...now browsing by author

Bio

Reference Librarian

“Hey Down in Front”

Last week they cut the ribbon on the new arena on Flatbush and Atlantic.  Phone booths around town have been promoting today’s opening date.

Montague Street phone booth, 2012; M. Jasper collection.

I have tickets for the venue’s premiere college basketball two-header, featuring the Kentucky Wildcats v. the Maryland Terrapins. I’ll be rooting for Kentucky, which was also the home state of Brooklyn historian Clay Lancaster, who penned the first landmark designation report for the LPC, on Brooklyn Heights, one of the adjacent neighborhoods to Downtown Brooklyn.

The intersection of Flatbush and Atlantic has again found itself in the crosshairs of sports, real estate and local pride.  In the 1950s, there used to be a ballpark that was almost built on the site for the Brooklyn Dodgers, who were taken to Los Angeles as the Nets have been from New Jersey.

Downtown Brooklyn is a curious area, both re-imaginable and steadfast to tradition, bordered by Flatbush, Atlantic, Court Street and Tillary.  As the prime office zone of Brooklyn, for most of the century the borough’s tallest building, the Williamsburgh Savings Bank, stood on the outskirts of the business district where today the tallest modular building in the world is planned.

The geography of Downtown Brooklyn cannot get any bigger, because of three landmarked districts at each edge: Brooklyn Heights, Fort Greene and Boerum Hill, plus the nexus coilings and byways at the exits for the Manhattan and Brooklyn Bridges.

But Downtown Brooklyn is posed to grow inside the minds of New Yorkers, with a new Skyscraper District launching up steel and glass, and a new recreation and residence hub launching in mass people to make transit and livelihood.

Downtown Brooklyn looking west from Williamsburg Bank Tower, ca. 1970; V1973.2.350, Photographic Collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

Atlantic Avenue, ca. 1948; Downtown Brooklyn Development Association records, 1979.021; Photographic Collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

The consequence of more traffic, however, may make the area seem smaller.  People who would drive in to the Harlem Globetrotters game or Leonard Cohen concert will be encouraged to save time and money on the train over the eternal city bane of parking.

In Satchmo, the autobiography of Louis Armstrong, the legendary jazz bandleader writes of growing up in the section of the port city of New Orleans he calls “Back o’ Town.”  It was the 1910s, and New Orleans also had an Uptown, Downtown, and “Front o’ Town.”

In topographical relation to the borough, Downtown Brooklyn is a nub of waterfront land toward the top west part of the island county.  Doesn’t it fit the mind and habitude of Brooklyners as a “Front O’ Town?”  And only perhaps to Manhattanites as “Back o’ Town.”

In 1853 the City of Brooklyn was consolidated by the absorption of outer territories known as Williamsburgh and Bushwick.  Borough Hall was built in the area and commerce has since revolved around it.

Borough Hall when first built in 1846; V1973.01.36; Non-photographic collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

Brooklyn Bureau of Community Services Collection,ca. 1946, V1991.110.223; Photographic Collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

Today, Front o’ Town is buoyed by visitor information maps and legends to the outlying areas.  I pass by these signs on my morning walk to work from Clinton Hill:

Downtown info map, Flatbush & Myrtle; M. Jasper collection.

MetroTech Center map; M. Jasper collection.

The 14 buildings of MetroTech Center have evolved over the last 30 years as the stretch of Flatbush extension sprouts sheer residential high-rises.

15 MetroTech Center; M. Jasper collection.

Myrtle and Flatbush Aves.

In 2008, New York University absorbed what in 1854 was established as the Brooklyn Collegiate and Polytechnic Institute.  This move might have been Manhattan’s revenge on Brooklyn for creating a rival basketball team.  NYU-Poly has a Residence Hall named after Mr. and Mrs. Donald F. Othmer (1904-1995), who was hailed as “the Hoyle of chemical engineering.”  Othmer taught at Brooklyn Poly and was instrumental in defrigeration, explosives, and while at Eastman Kodak worked on solving flammability problems for the preservation of acetate movie film.  A devoted Trustee of Brooklyn Historical Society, the library was dedicated to Othmer in 1992.

An early reference to “downtown Brooklyn” in the Brooklyn Daily Eagle is found in an 1875 real estate ad for “houses on the Hill” on Dekalb Avenue. The location touts a primacy of transit access, encouraging future inhabitants to come “from OVERCROWDED UP TOWN, New York… from OVERCHARGED DOWN TOWN, Brooklyn…”

BROOKLYN EAGLE POST CARD, SERIES 20, NO. 115. / JUNCTION FULTON STREET AND DEKALB AVENUE ABOUT 1850. Site of the Dime Savings Bank; V1973.4.38 a-d; Postcard Collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

Some blocks away on Flatbush and present-day Livingston is Labon’s Inn, a quaff-and-chat parlor.

Labon's Inn, ca. 1850; V1973.5.1262; Brooklyn photograph and illustration collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

In 1929, civic leaders organized the Downtown Brooklyn Development Association (DBDA) to improve business conditions in the area.  BHS archives includes a rich collection devoted to the group.

“Approximately 50,000 persons gain their livelihood in the Downtown Area and are housed within it every working day.” DBDA recognizes covering 8 acres where thru-passers “consume daily at least one meal in the area.”

The area is continually cited as a blight to civic functioning.  As early as 1900, the traffic conditions in the area were noted to be treacherous.

Brooklyn Safety Council, ca. 1930; V1973.5.1118; Brooklyn photograph and illustration collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

The 1929 DBDA reports that “the Downtown Commercial Area has been considered a Bonanza section by the three industries represented” by beggars, peddlers and “pullers-in,” the latter an old-timey “portal solicitation” by hawkers at the door of the establishment, a “nefarious practice.”

Better Business Bureau brochures, 1946-57; Downtown Brooklyn Development Association records, 1979.021, Box 1; Brooklyn Historical Society.

In 1931, the Brooklyn Evening Journal quoted Democratic Party boss John H. McCooey referring to the territory at the mouth of Brooklyn Bridge as “an eyesore and a disgrace to the city.”

Long’s Hat Store at 389 Fulton Street won top prize in a 1929 citywide Show Window Display Contest conducted by the Electrical Association of New York, Inc.  In 1936, the winners were Frederick Loeser & Co. at 484 Fulton, and William Wise & Son, Inc. at 288 Livingston St.

Annual window display competition, 1929-1936; Downtown Brooklyn Development Association records, 1979.021, Box 1; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Mr. Fulton, Flatbush & Fulton; M. Jasper collection.

They built an elevated train along Fulton Ave. in 1885.  The DBDA records at BHS detail the celebrations and visionary fundraising which hailed its demolition in 1942.

FULTON STREET FROM DUFFIELD, 1941; V1987.10.5, Percy Varian Photographic Collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

Fulton and Smith Streets, 1941; V1987.10.10, Percy Varian Photographic Collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

In 1996, a study by the Chamber of Commerce reported the median household income of shoppers at Fulton Mall was $25,800.  Binkin’s was still the oldest bookstore in the borough at 54 Willoughby:

Downtown Brooklyn : a plan for continued progress, 1996, Othmer Library, Brooklyn Historical Society.

The Brooklyn Civic Center, conceived in the decade following WWII, proposed to reinvigorate with court houses and statues a neighborhood of rundown tenements and “gypsy tea-rooms.”  The deteriorated state of the off-ramp areas of the Brooklyn Bridge was compared to a new plaza, never implemented, dedicated to George Washington:

Brooklyn Bridge plaza, 1931-1941; Downtown Brooklyn Development Association records, 1979.021, Box 1; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Brooklyn Bridge plaza, 1931-1941; Downtown Brooklyn Development Association records, 1979.021, Box 1; Brooklyn Historical Society.

As assessment was made for a Title I slum clearance project at Cadman Plaza. The below 1959 map shows Title I areas in black and vacant or “sub-standard” and “suitable for rehabilitation” in gray.

Cadman Plaza: slum clearance plan under Title I of the Housing Act of 1949, 1958, Othmer Library, Brooklyn Historical Society.

The Plaza is named in honor of Bishop S. Parkes Cadman, the progressive and popular “radio pastor” of the Central Congregational Church of Brooklyn. Cadman was a roistering polemicist and wrote books on Darwin and Memory.  It was Bishop Cadman who in 1913 quipped the nickname for the gothic Woolworth Building, the world’s tallest, as the “Cathedral of Commerce.”

Bishop Cadman illustrated bookplate; Emma Toedteberg bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

In a 1941 letter to the Downtown Brooklyn Association, Brooklyn Justice Lewis L. Fawcett invests the memorial of Cadman with evangelical zeal as “a monument to the eternal religion such as we only see in old Europe… in which you feel you have the spirit of God.”  Justice Fawcett assures that the elevated structures adjoining the plaza will have been duly removed prior to the Dedication.

Cadman Plaza also includes a bust of William Jay Gaynor, the only mayor of New York to have been shot by an assassin.

William Jay Gaynor, Cadman Plaza; M. Jasper collection.

William Jay Gaynor, NYPL digital collection.

Today, Brooklyners visit the Supreme Court to report for jury duty or search probate records.

Supreme Court, Cadman Plaza; M. Jasper collection.

In the 1980s, downtown showed a majority of buildings built before 1945, some of which were built as part of past development projects.

Downtown Brooklyn : a report, Regional Plan Association, 1983; Othmer Library, Brooklyn Historical Society.

The year one : a brief statement of some of the activities of Downtown Brooklyn Association Incorporated during its first year, 1929, Othmer Library, Brooklyn Historical Society.

The year one : a brief statement of some of the activities of Downtown Brooklyn Association Incorporated during its first year, 1929, Othmer Library, Brooklyn Historical Society.

When the Brooklyn Dodgers sought to relocate in the 1950s, Dodgers President Walter O’Malley, a former General Counsel for the ball club, brainstormed the idea of a stadium enclosed by a translucent roof, where weather conditions would not cancel a day at the ballpark and better lighting could be arranged for night games.   “There is psychological reasons [sic] in favor of translucent material rather than concrete construction to properly set the stage for the playing of a game that is traditionally an outdoor one.” O’Malley’s papers are collected at BHS, which include correspondence with the Owens-Corning Fiberglass Co. regarding technical details, where O’Malley suggests the finished structure might be a new “wonder of the world.”

O’Malley reached out to hypermodernists like Eero Saarinen at M.I.T., who designed Idlewild Airport, Norman Bel Geddes, the Art Deco master, and even R. Buckminster Fuller, the philosopher architectonicist, who lived in Forest Hills. O’Malley was intrigued by Fuller’s article in American Fabrics on the concept of the Dymaxion.  Fuller’s idea, among others, is to provide the best fully usable structure at least cost to the consumer of Spaceship Earth. In his letter, O’Malley admits that the price of the faux-open stadium exceeds the Dodgers budget.  “Baseball companies unfortunately, do not have the resources of the large industrial companies.”

Maybe if Bucky had designed the new stadium the Dodgers would have been accused of taking L.A. to Brooklyn rather than taking Brooklyn to L.A.

City Construction Coordinator Robert Moses suspected O’Malley of trying to finagle city funds designed for public use to build the new stadium. O’Malley evaded the suggestion and appealed to Moses’ concern by reiterating what he said at “our luncheon meeting” about the public purpose problem of parking.

Walter O'Malley letter, 1953; Walter O'Malley papers, 2004.003; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Good parking was a prime moving force for Moses, as it has become in the opening of the new arena.  But Moses wasn’t sold:

Robert Moses letter, 1955; Walter O'Malley papers, 2004.003; Brooklyn Historical Society.

He insisted that “the establishment of a new Dodger stadium is not of itself and by itself, a public purpose.”  But for the next fifty years the public of Brooklyn thought otherwise.

O’Malley despaired that horseracing would surpass baseball for New York sports fans, since the turf “found a way to get State legislation and financing for a super-colossal proposed racetrack.”  Plans were also put forth to relocate the stadium to various points in Queens.  This might have been more an affront to Brooklyners than the move to L.A.

Brooklyn Dodgers airplane in flight, ca.1955; V1991.52.1, Photographic Collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

Today’s Atlantic Yards project roiled over similar development of antiquated mass transit and land use, the way that the Brooklyn Bridge killed the ferry business but blighted surrounding neighborhoods.

Brooklyn Bridge construction, 1874 Beers Atlas, Othmer Library, Brooklyn Historical Society.

See the pre-developed intersection of Atlantic and Flatbush in 1983, cited as ripe for “visual improvements:”

Downtown Brooklyn : a report, Regional Plan Association, 1983; Othmer Library, Brooklyn Historical Society.

Today one can get burgers, franks and thick shakes at Shake Shack on Adams Street, which must have fit the bill of visual improvement.

The corridors of Downtown Brooklyn may sometimes seem unsightly and inhibit a visual writability besides the ads for children’s dentists and underwear spreads for pretty big and tall ladies, yet such a madcap civic predicament both makes secret the old architectural touches and grandstands the strike and rush of moving life.  Anyone whose routine demands the threshold of Downtown knows it, beating sparks from the shoulders of Court Street stenographers, Jay Street bus drivers, Fulton Street shop barkers, Macy’s counter girls, NYU Polytechnic maintenance workers, Lawrence Street souvlaki-slingers, records room clerks in teeshirts and sneakers, lunch hour jurors, office furniture truck drivers, Schermerhorn Street bailmakers, City Tech students, process servers eating 99cent slices, the crazy man on a tirade at the halal wagon outside the Transit building…

Joraleman Street, Borough Hall, 2012; M. Jasper collection.

Downtown Brooklyn, 2012; M. Jasper collection.

Homage to Downtown Brooklyn, 1967, V1993.7.1; Photographic Collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

Fulton Mall, 2012; M. Jasper collection.

Fulton Mall, 2012; M. Jasper collection.

Homage to Downtown Brooklyn, 1967, V1993.7.3 Photographic Collection, Brooklyn Historical Society.

The saga of Atlantic Yards has been dispatched to a creative and exhaustive parameter on numerous hotwires.  And don’t forget that the New York Islanders will still skate the island, and face off in the team’s new digs against the New Jersey Devils opening game next month.

Emma Toedteberg Bookplate Collection, 1701-1982 (2012.004)

To view the Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection finding aid click here.  If you would like to view any materials from this collection please email library reference to schedule an appointment.

I’m stingy grown
What’s mine’s my own
-motto, unknown bookplate.

A bookplate is a label pasted to the inside cover of a book that indicates ownership in a personal or institutional library collection.

Edwin Lewton Penny bookplate; Non-Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Employees' Library bookplate; Institutional Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Emma Toedteberg, librarian at the Long Island Historical Society from 1889 to 1936, was a devout collector of bookplates, also known as “ex libris.”  It was a passion inspired by her father, Augustus Toedteberg, a prolific Brooklyn illustrator noted for theater portraits and dramatic scenes. Toedteberg illustrated a 54 volume Records of the Stage, and was known as “Dean of the Corps” among book and print collectors of the American theater, which included over one thousand rare playbills.

Emma Toedteberg bookplate; Non-Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Augustus Toedteberg bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Augustus Toedteberg bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Emma expanded her father’s collection of bookplates to number over 7,000 and housed the collection in a “massive oaken cabinet… almost six feet in height” with “forty-four glass-topped drawers” filed with “neat piles of bookplates.” The cabinet stood behind the reference desk “in what used to be called the ‘Ladies Parlor,’” where Emma held court with her assistants, Miss Prentice and Miss Tuttle. (North, Edgerton G., “The Society’s Bookplates” (1964) The Century Book, LIHS, chap. 4).  The collection was later added to by Harriet Stryker-Rodda, librarian at the Society in the 1960s who published guides to genealogical research, Brooklyn church records and colonial handwriting.

The art and industry of bookplates originated with the first printing of books in Germany in the mid-15th century.  Some of the earliest bookplates in the United States appeared in the personal libraries of Southern royalists known as the “Virginia Cavaliers,” and showed the influence and patterns of English heraldry (The Curio, “American Book-Plates and their Engravers”). Yet, says bookplate writer Theodore Wesley Koch, a Dante scholar who worked at the Library of Congress at the turn of the century, “armorial plates are in questionable taste for most American families.”  Still, Paul Revere, the New England horseback rabble-rouser against British occupation, made a living as a copperplate printer and engraved colonial bookplates in the Tory tradition:

Gardiner Chandler bookplate, by Paul Revere; Illustrated Bookplates; Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Paul Revere bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Some bookplates forgo the intricacies of history and symbols, like the ex libris of Colonel Alden Spooner, a printer who in 1811 founded the Long Island Star, which acted as the official paper for three counties, Kings, Queens and Suffolk.

Alden Spooner bookplate; American Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

The personal bookplate of Emma Toedteberg was engraved by Edwin Davis French (1851-1906), who studied at the Art Students’ League and served a stint as the League’s President. French engraved and designed over 200 bookplates for esteemed collectors and institutions, and designed plates for his personal collection of international language books, with an emphasis on Volapuk, a constructed language devised in 1879 by Johann Martin Schleyer, a German priest.

Edwin D. French bookplate; Engravers of Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Bookplates by French:

Long Island Historical Society - Storrs Memorial Fund bookplate; Engravers of Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Edwin D. French bookplate; Engravers of Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Lucy Wharton Drexell bookplate; Engravers of Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

By Edwin D. French bookplate; Engravers of Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

In the Ladies Parlor, Emma also collected a rich selection of bookplates owned by women:

Euphenia Davidson bookplate; Ladies' Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Caroline Monk bookplate; Ladies' Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Sonia Anne Clifford bookplate; Ladies' Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Jeanette Latou Dickinson bookplate; Ladies' Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Often the bookplate shared by a married couple is filed under the lady’s name:

Theo & Bertha Obermeyer bookplate; Ladies' Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Bookplate collecting veered between a study and a hobby. Bookplates were sold at auction like paintings and acquired by institutions such as the British Museum, with a collection of over 35,000 plates. At its least artful the bookplate was a name-tag: “Many estimable people find a difficulty in distinguishing between mine and thine in books as well as in umbrellas” (Koch, “A Defense of Bookplates,” 1915). The literature of bookplates at the turn of the century is often persnickety and highfalutin. “A taste in books may be easily whitewashed,” says Temple Scott, a Gilded Age editor and bibliographer, “but a taste in a book-plate flares its owner’s heart right into the eyes of the demurest damsel or the simplest swain.”  The bookplate owner is sworn to protect the virtue of the book: “He who could find it in his heart to write on title-pages could surely commit a murder.”

Tis meat and drink to me to see a fool.”
-motto, bookplate of Mrs. St. Leger Harrison.

The index to the Emma bookplates lists many bookplate owners as bankers, statesmen, actors, lawyers, “capitalists,” and one “gem expert.”  The art and collecting of bookplates was chiefly an upper-middle class practice. In the indexes, one does not find bakers, dock workers, or sandhogs.  As Temple Scott again chimes in, “the average mortal of this work-a-day world and age has not the means wherewith to acquire such treasures of the bibliophile. Nor, perhaps, has he the pedigree with which to adorn them.”  Temple Scott managed John Lane publishing house on Fifth Avenue, and in 1902 was accused of stealing $7,000 from the company- perhaps “means wherewith to acquire such treasures of the bibliophile.”

Koch, T.W. "A Defense of Bookplates" (1915) Some American College Bookplates, ed. Ward, H.P.

The oldest institutional plate in the Emma collection dates to 1759, for the Albany Society Library of colonial New York:

Albany Society Library bookplate; Institutional Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Among the oldest undated is the bookplate of Gilbert Burnet, Bishop of Salisbury (1643-1715), which features the Virgin Mother & Son of God, and a hunting horn:

Bishop Burnet bookplate; Illustrated Bookpaltes, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Bishop Burnet bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

William Gifford Palgrave (1826-1888), a Jesuit spy in Syria and government agent in Abyssinia:

William Gifford Palgrave bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

William Gifford Palgrave bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Captain Inglefield, who in 1782 perished in the wreck of His Majesty’s ship, The Centaur:

Captain Inglefield bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Lord Byron, the Romantic poet, who Augustus Toedteberg admired and kept a scrapbook devoted to:

Lord Byron bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Lord Byron bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Marie Antoinette:

Marie Antoinette bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Marie Antoinette bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Jack & Charmian London:

Jack London bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Charmian London bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Jack & Charmian London bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

The Lotos Club:

Lotos Club bookplate; Institutional Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Lotos Club bookplate; Institutional Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

The bookplate of John Jacob Raskob, a vice president of General Motors, chairman of the Democratic National Committee in the 1920s, and the man behind the money that built the Empire State Building – in 1929 Raskob wrote an article for Ladies Home Journal called “Everybody Ought to be Rich“:

John Jacob Raskob bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates; Emma Toedteberg bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

John Jacob Raskob bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Francis Wilson bookplate; Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Henry Stacy Marks bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Richard Southcote Millsergh bookplate; Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Frederick Starr bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Frederick Starr bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Frederick Starr bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Frederick Starr bookplate; Illustrated Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

A bookplate might mark the gift to a library collection:

Newark Public Library bookplate; Institutional Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

The American Merchant Marine Library Association gift bookplate; Institutional Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

American Seamen's Friend Society bookplate; Institutional Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

Emma’s collection also includes boxes of plates by individual engravers.  John Evans (1855-1943) was an award-winning artist and wood-cut engraver from Brooklyn. A distinguished Freemason, Evans provided illustrations for turn of the century weekly magazines, and was noted as the last of a generation of flourishing woodcut artists from the late nineteenth century.  Evans’ portrait shows the apparatus used for his art.

John Evans, The Century Book, Long Island Historical Society, 1964 (Reference F116.L66 C46 1964).

Paradise bookplate; Engravers of Bookplates, Emma Toedteberg Bookplate collection, 2012.004; Brooklyn Historical Society.

A hoary romance:

The Bookplate Booklet (May 1919) ed. by Fowler, Alfred, Kansas City, MO.

Bookplate Resources:

*A good lively blog.
*Book and print history at The Private Library.
*The American Society of Bookplate Collectors & Designers
*Story about a Smithsonian curator and bookplate scholar.
*Bibliographical Society of the University of Virginia
*Society for the History of Authorship, Reading and Publishing
*The Bookplate Society

High Iron

Last December, the Landmark Preservation Commission proposed to designate a section of Downtown Brooklyn as the “Borough Hall Skyscraper District.” The buildings in the district, described here, were mostly built between 1901 and 1927, when Brooklyn was believed to have a future as a financial hub, but the district also includes landmark status for Borough Hall, where at one time the old Mayor of Brooklyn held office -  so if it is a strange mis-characterization to refer to any part of Brooklyn as a “Skyscraper District” – as if Brooklyn ever cared for skyscrapers  – at least the district gives a nod to when Brooklyn was its own city, “not a suburb or a borough or a place to which taxi drivers object to driving you” (Brock, H.I. “And Now Brooklyn Raises a Skyline,” NY Times, May 22, 1927, Brooklyn Historical Society Scrapbook Collection).

Use A

26 Court Street & Montague-Court Building, private collection of M. Jasper, NYC.

The New York skyscraper is a conjuration of Manhattan, the skinny guy to Brooklyn’s fat guy. One enters Manhattan from an underground tunnel opening to the tallest city in the world. To get to Brooklyn, one crosses New York City’s true first skyscraper, the Brooklyn Bridge, and descends upon the low island. They said it couldn’t be built, but the Brooklyn Bridge rises 276 feet above the surface of the East River at high tide, which in 1883 was taller than any of the newborn office buildings cropped up around Manhattan’s Newspaper Row.

Brooklyn-Bridge-&-Manhattan

Brooklyn Bridge & Manhattan skyline, private collection of M. Jasper, NYC.

People born in Brooklyn don’t say they’re from New York, but say “I’m from Brooklyn.”  The borough has its own museum, park, accent, a Post Office of majestic magnitude greater than had in most major cities, and more residents than Paris.  And the best New York movie is Saturday Night Fever, set in 1970s Bay Ridge.  But as tall towers boomed for Brooklyn in the 1920s, NY Times writer H.I. Brock worried that “nobody knows how far the rivalry with Manhattan will have been pushed.”

Times 1927 A

Brooklyn Historical Society, Scrapbook Collection.

H.I. is elegiac when he cites statistics from a group called “Bigger and Better Brooklyn,” and indicates the Hotel Margaret, since burned down, at Columbia Heights and Orange Street, as for years the “sharpest accent of that skyline.”

Hotel Margaret, postcard, 1911, Brooklyn Historical Society, Photo Collection

Hotel Margaret, postcard, 1911, Brooklyn Historical Society, Photo Collection.

View from Hotel Margaret, ca. 1900, Brooklyn Historical Society, Photo Collection

View from Hotel Margaret, ca. 1900, Brooklyn Historical Society, Photo Collection.

The storefronts and tenements “have been looking down on Court Street for generations. Now Court Street looks down upon them.”

Boro Hall ca. 1918 / "Human fly" climbing Borough Hall / flagpole / taken from 32 Court St.

Boro Hall c. 1918 / "Human fly" climbing Borough Hall / flagpole / taken from 32 Court St., Brooklyn Historical Society, Photo Collection.

It does not seem natural to suddenly perceive a horizontal place as a place that is vertical. But Brooklyn has a mixed relationship with skyscrapers.  The island is not ripe for the engineering of skyward architecture.  With its own deep indigenous bedrock, which juts out of Central Park, Manhattan is full of schist.  Brooklyn veers horizontal because its foundation at the waterfront, where trade and transport huddles, is soft.  The Dutch settlers, foremost keen to trade, called the island “broken land.”  Not so safe for deep-stook steel rising up where the clouds roll by.

A 1941 WPA historical survey, “The Indians of Brooklyn in the Days of the Dutch,” which includes original hand-sketched maps and tipped in document plates, notes that the Downtown section of the proposed Skyscraper District was referred to by its indigenous corn-growing settlers as Marechkawieck, which translates from the Munsee Delaware dialect as “the sandy place” (also Grumet, R.S. Native American Place Names, 1981, Brooklyn Historical Soc. Library Stacks).

WPA2

"The Indians of Brooklyn in the Days of the Dutch," ed. MacLeod, W.C., Brooklyn Historical Society, Library Stacks.

WPA-1

"The Indians of Brooklyn in the Days of the Dutch," ed. MacLeod, W.C., Brooklyn Historical Society, Library Stacks.

WPA3

"The Indians of Brooklyn in the Days of the Dutch," ed. MacLeod, W.C., Brooklyn Historical Society, Library Stacks.

The Triassic history of NYC is described in a 1930 oversized tract, The Physiography of the New York Region, which explains the “relatively recent sand plains of Brooklyn and Long Island….”

Physiopgraphic provinces A

The Physiography of the New York Region, by Lobeck, A.K.; Raisz, E.J.; Dickinson, R.L., Brooklyn Historical Society, Map Collection.

Physiographic provinces B

The Physiography of the New York Region, by Lobeck, A.K.; Raisz, E.J.; Dickinson, R.L., Brooklyn Historical Society, Map Collection.

Brooklyn’s Boerum Hill neighborhood was once home to “Little Caughnawaga,” a community of descendants of the Mohawk tribe who excelled as steelworkers for the city in the sky. The Mohawk men from a young age were said to flourish in “high iron,” and since at least the 1920s worked in riveting gangs, “the glamor boys of structural steel work.”  Mohawk families left the Caughnawaga reservation in Canada, where the tribe was led by its women, driven by horticulture, and guided by the Three Sisters, “who were the spirits of the corn, bean and the squash.”  The onset of modern times turned the tribe from corn to steel, and the family seed-sowers from the ladies to the men, who husbanded the Empire State Building, Rockefeller Center, and George Washington Bridge (“Scientific Possibilities in Iroquoian Studies” (Freilich, M.  Anthropologica, vol. 5, #2, 1963).

A National Geographic article from 1952, “The Mohawks Scrape the Sky,” paints a detailed portrait of Little Caughnawaga’s Mohawk steelworkers, and vaguely comments with the removed supremacy of mid-century ethnography that there is “no sure explanation” for the Mohawk’s “relative freedom from fear of heights.”

Mohawks2

"The Mohawks Scrape the Sky," Conly, R. Brooklyn Historical Society, Library Stacks.

Mohawks1

"The Mohawks Scrape the Sky," Conly, R. Brooklyn Historical Society, Library Stacks.

Mohawks3

"The Mohawks Scrape the Sky," Conly, R. Brooklyn Historical Society, Library Stacks.

The local Cuyler Presbyterian Church, on Pacific Street, was increasingly attended by Mohawk Christians, and in 1957 Pastor David Cory edited a translation of Christian hymns into Mohawk dialect, as well as transcriptions of tribal hymns like “The Great King,” set to an “old Caughnawaga melody.”

Kanawake Teieriwakwata, trans by Mrs.' Lahache, M. &  Schmidt, J.S. May 1957, Brooklyn Historical Society, Closed Stacks.

Kanawake Teieriwakwata, trans by Mrs.' Lahache, M. & Schmidt, J.S. May 1957, Brooklyn Historical Society, Closed Stacks.

Kanawake Teieriwakwata, trans by Mrs.' Lahache, M. &  Schmidt, J.S. May 1957, Brooklyn Historical Society, Closed Stacks.

Kanawake Teieriwakwata, trans by Mrs.' Lahache, M. & Schmidt, J.S. May 1957, Brooklyn Historical Society, Closed Stacks.

Kanawake Teieriwakwata 3

Kanawake Teieriwakwata, trans by Mrs.' Lahache, M. & Schmidt, J.S. May 1957, Brooklyn Historical Society, Closed Stacks.

The public hearing last December before the Landmarks Commission over the proposed Borough Hall Skyscraper District provoked many a yea & nay.  The loudest dissent, as reported in the Brooklyn Daily Eagle, reasoned that “increased maintenance fees and additional special assessments” would malign local real estate costs.  Historically, people come to Brooklyn before Manhattan because it’s bigger and cheaper.  So that to live in the sky above Brooklyn, so landmarked, it will naturally cost more.  Borough President Marty Markowitz, who works in Borough Hall, assured that the plan won’t be “financially onerous.”  Still, a tenant rep at 26 Court Street called the layout “a jigsaw piece,” and the Brooklyn Heights Courier quoted a letter to the city by a consortia of commercial building interests, that the district portrays a “sad chapter in Downtown’s economic, political, social and cultural history” (“Tower Power,” Fox, A. Dec. 17-23, 2010).

In 2005, Downtown Brooklyn was rezoned for residential use, and has since skyrocketed in population to 12,000 residents, up from only 400 counted in the 2000 Census. (Gottesdiener, L. “Boomtown!” Brooklyn Heights Courier, Mar 11-17, 2011).  And Atlantic Yards may soon be home to the tallest prefab structure in the world.  No matter how beanstalked, Brooklyn is still the Borough of Homes.

Use B

26 Court Street & Montague-Court Building, private collection of M. Jasper, NYC.

The last word is had by old Junior’s Cheesecake, the anchorage of Flatbush Avenue, whose menu offers the legacy of a sweet and holy totem:

Jrs X

152 Henry Street

152 Henry Street, a four story red-bricked Greek Revival multiple dwelling, could be the last Single Room Occupancy in Brooklyn Heights from the 19th century.

152 Henry Street, Brooklyn Heights, 2010

Landmarked in 1965, the Brooklyn Heights neighborhood served as the city’s inaugural landmark designation. The subsequent designation report is brief and scantly detailed, but preservationist and Kentucky-native Clay Lancaster wrote a definitive history of the neighborhood, Old Brooklyn Heights, which is commonly perceived as the surrogate designation report for the area.  However, in his book, Lancaster does not mention 152 Henry Street.

Self-effacing in its charmed simplicity, 152 Henry is overshadowed by its more traditionally historic neighbors, like the quaint gingerbread-house coziness of 156 Henry Street, which is now a CVS pharmacy.

A Single Room Occupancy, or SRO, follows different housing rules than regular apartments.  The rent is cheaper than most apartments, but tenants must forgo typical amenities.   SROs usually follow stringent rules against co-ed occupancy.

I first heard that 152 Henry Street was an SRO from a friend who dwelled there and waited tables at Peter Luger Steakhouse.  He’d heard about the place from another waiter at Luger’s, since retired, who lived at 152 for many years.

152 Henry is peculiar, almost from another era, like an all-male bachelor’s boarding house before World War I, when single living situations abided a different social expectation. It is an anomalous, word-of-mouth, somewhat impenetrable happenstance in the midst of one of the most unique and highly-prized neighborhoods in New York City.

You won’t find an ad on Craig’s List for a room at 152 Henry, or as you might have found in the classifieds of the old Brooklyn Daily Eagle, where, in 1895, the terms of rent were $2 per week.  In 1878, when the building was advertised as “handsomely furnished,” rooms were offered with “ample closets” (these days the closets have been converted into individual rooms):

1878-ad

… Or in 1864, when a “parlor and bedroom” for a “gentleman and wife” were available, as was a “hall room” for a single gentleman.

1864 ad

Note the building’s address as “130 Henry.”  Street addresses in Brooklyn Heights changed in 1870.  I found evidence of the building’s old address by consulting our library’s rich collection of Historical Atlases.

A “hall room” sounds like an appropriate, and classier, description of the rooms today in 152 Henry Street.  Traces of the building’s modern use as an SRO are reflected in an ad from 1863:

1863 ad

In 1891, an unfortunate incident occurred outside 152 Henry.  According to two pieces in the Brooklyn Daily Eagle, dated July 28 and July 30, Dr. Helene Lassen, “a well proportioned and rather good looking woman of middle age… privileged to place the letters M.D. at the end of her name… had an experience with dogcatchers this morning which she evidently won’t forget in a hurry.”  Dr. Lassen left her residence at 152 Henry to walk her dog, Laddy, a “thoroughbred pug and not as ugly as the general run of this class of dogs.”  Laddy was not on a leash, since Dr. Lassen admitted she only took Laddy out this day “for a romp,” but he was duly tagged on his collar.  The pug ran off down the street, but before his owner could retrieve him, the local dogcatcher, “a big brute of a man,” snatched up Laddy by the hind legs.

Dr. Lassen caught up to the brute and took hold of Laddy’s fore-end, and the two proceeded to have a tug of war over the pug, until the dogcatcher struck the doctor and knocked her down, and tossed Laddy in his wagon with other kidnapped curs.  Dr. Lassen jumped into the wagon to save the dog, but was again assaulted by the “burly brute,” who absconded with Laddy.

Dr. Lassen was advised to complain to the office of Mayor Alfred Clark Chapin.  She eventually freed little Laddy from the pound, but after pressing charges against the dogcatcher, she was told that since the pug was not on a leash, she indeed had broken the law, and was “prevented from prosecuting the assailant of herself and her pet.”  Said the Eagle, “the shock to her nervous system was very great, and her shoulder is still bruised and sore.”

The next morning Dr. Lassen gained a bizarre sense of closure, when she received a creepy anonymous letter at her home, written with a thuggish level of literacy:

letter

These dognapping brigands would have a fine time today, by the preponderance of Brooklyn dog owners who leave their pets leashed to the parking meter while going inside to have lunch or do their shopping, leaving poor Bowser to languish on the sidewalk.

The writers for the Eagle can’t help describing Dr. Lassen’s attractive physical features before noting her profession as a doctor, for which, being a female in 1891, she is “privileged.” She was victimized by hoods on both the street and City Hall.  152 Henry Street, besides letting rooms to single bachelors, as was the custom of the day, was also once the home of a stalwart lady of class and manner with an independent medical practice – which was not the custom of the day.

In the future, whenever 152 Henry phases out its SRO status, a bygone legacy of apartment living in Brooklyn will have phased out too, one which it could be assumed would have been long extinct anyway, like Automats or subway tokens, or when single gentlemen lived in boarding houses for $2 per week.